Why Age is an Advantage

Why Age is an Advantage - Illustration of an older woman's head (left) and a younger woman's head (right) showing various states of metastasis in each brain

CCR researchers studying mice found that a younger immune system supports the metastasis of breast cancer cells to the brain whereas an older immune system makes the brain less hospitable to breast cancer cells. On the left, an older woman’s silhouette is overlaid with a scene of small metastatic tumors and a few immune cells and neurons. On the right, in a younger woman’s silhouette, there are many more metastatic tumors, neurons and immune cells. In the team’s experiments, they found that immune cells in a younger setting promote the survival of metastatic breast cancer cells. Credit: Veronica Falconieri Hays, Falconieri Visuals, LLC

The risk of being diagnosed with breast cancer increases with age. Yet, the risk of a poor outcome is higher for women who are diagnosed when they are young. Although only seven percent of women diagnosed with breast cancer are 40 years of age or younger, many of those cancers are lethal. Patients in this age group usually endure intense treatment, but many find their disease recurs and spreads. Compared to patients diagnosed later in life, they are more likely to develop metastatic tumors in the brain. The tumors can be treated with radiation or surgery, but they often return.

Scientists have struggled to understand the more aggressive nature of breast cancer in young women. Now, Senior Investigator Patricia Steeg, Ph.D., and her team think they have an answer. The key difference between young and old, they say, may be less about the tumor cells themselves, and more about the tumor microenvironment in which those cells travel and grow. Steeg’s team has found evidence in animal studies, reported in Clinical Cancer Research, that a younger immune system supports breast cancer’s metastasis to the brain, whereas an older immune system makes the brain less hospitable to migrating breast cancer cells.

To investigate whether identical cancer cells behave differently in young animals than they do in older ones, Steeg, Senior Investigator Lalage Wakefield, D.Phil., and postdoctoral fellow Alex Man Lai Wu, Ph.D., injected human breast cancer cells into mice of different ages and then monitored those mice for metastases. The mice in their experiments developed similar numbers of metastatic tumors in their livers and lungs, regardless of age. But the situation was different in the brain. Steeg’s team found up to four times more metastases in the brain of young animals than in older animals.

Patricia Steeg

Patricia S. Steeg, Ph.D.
Deputy Chief

Women's Malignancies Branch

The team traced this effect to age-related differences in the immune system. They found that in young animals, the brain contains more infiltrating macrophages and microglia — immune cells that are capable of both fighting tumors and protecting them, depending on circumstances. Macrophages and microglia were not only more abundant in the brains of young animals, they also behaved differently. According to the team’s experiments, in the brains of young animals, these immune cells promote the survival of metastatic cancer cells.

Based on her team’s findings, Steeg is optimistic that modifying the immune environment might help stave off brain metastasis in young patients with breast cancer. The young mice in their experiments developed significantly fewer brain metastases when they were given a drug that reduced macrophages and microglia, making the immune environment in their brains more closely resemble that of older mice. They were able to achieve this by inhibiting an immune-system regulator called colony-stimulating factor-1 receptor. Steeg hopes a similar approach might benefit young patients with breast cancer, and she has begun investigating potential candidates for clinical studies.